Five Points, New York: A Journey Through the Most Notorious Urban Neighborhood

Five Points, New York: A Journey Through the Most Notorious Urban Neighborhood

For many, New York City is the dream destination, offering visitors and residents access to some of the world’s best facilities, including restaurants, theaters, and gyms. Still, the city has outlived some notoriously poverty-ridden districts, like Five Points in Lower Manhattan.

In the 19th century, the area was infamous for unsanitary living conditions, high crime rates, and extreme poverty.

Five Points was named for the intersection of five streets: Mulberry, Little Water, Orange, Cross, and Anthony. The region holds significant historical and cultural importance in American history due to immigration, social challenges, crime, culture, politics, and history.

Five Points exemplified the challenges and dynamics of urban immigration during the 19th century while revealing the harsh realities of urban life. American law enforcement practices were shaped by the Five Point neighborhood's notorious reputation.

The region has also contributed to the development of cultural innovation while triggering political and social reforms.

Let’s look at the details.

History of Five Points

Five Points became a notorious neighborhood in the early 19th century, known for its squalid living conditions and high crime rates. Its origin is rooted in the Collect Pond, which had been polluted with industrial waste. The pond was filled to create buildable land, but poor drainage created disease-ridden conditions.

Still, the area drew poor Irish and Italian immigrants with its affordable but poor-quality housing close to jobs in nearby towns. Soon, Five Points became a hotspot for social vices, overcrowding, and poverty.

Being the Collect Pond landfill, the area wasn’t suitable for high-quality construction. Instead, it attracted low-income residents to the small and cramped apartments. Rising immigration created crowded conditions, worsening living conditions.

Poverty and a lack of proper sewage systems led to frequent outbreaks of diseases like typhus and cholera. While the region boasted a vibrant street life, including music and dance, it soon gained a reputation as a dangerous and lawless slum.

The development of Five Points began when social reformers focused on improving living conditions, leading to the construction of Mulberry Bend Park in the 1890s. Large-scale urban renewal projects started to redevelop the area in the 19th and 20th centuries.

Several infamous residents ruled the Five Points streets and alleys, including:

John Morrissey

John Morrissey, a member of the Five Points Gang. An Irish immigrant, Morrissey earned fame as a bare-knuckle boxer. He later became a Democratic Party politician.

Paul Kelly

Paul Kelly was a prominent gangster who founded the Five Points Gang, one of the most powerful in New York City. Originally an Italian-American, Kelly’s gang produced mafia leaders like Lucky Luciano and Al Capone.

Hell-Cat Maggie

Popular for her fierce fighting skills, Hell-Cat Maggie was a feared female member of the Dead Rabbits Gang. She wore brass fingernails in street fights and filed her teeth into points.

William “Bill the Butcher” Poole

William Pool was a popular leader of the Bowery Boys. He opposed Irish immigrants and led several clashes with the rival Dead Rabbits.

Poole’s gang was at the center of various infamous activities, including gang warfare, with frequent violent confrontations between The Bowery Boys, Five Points Gang, and Dead Rabbits.

Five Points Infamy

Five Points, New York, was once one of the most dangerous areas in New York City. With several rival gangs operating in the area, violent street brawls, extortion, and theft were common occurrences.

The living conditions in the area were dire, with poor infrastructure, the frequent spread of diseases, and a lack of proper sanitation. The presence of brothels, gambling dens, and saloons marked a culture of vice and debauchery.

The Five Points area had a significant influence on popular culture and literature. Several TV series and films focus on the notorious region. Famous movies include “Gangs of New York,” “Copper,” and “The Alienist.” Literature like Maggie: A Girl of the Streets” by Stephen Crane, and “The Bonfire of the Vanities” by Tom Wolfe” offered a detailed account of life in Five Points.

The Five Points reform and improvement efforts include:

Efforts to Improve Conditions in Five Points, New York City

The Five Points, notorious for its slum conditions and rampant crime in the mid-19th century, became a focal point for reform efforts in New York City. Reform efforts included

• University Settlement Society: Founded in 1886, it was the first settlement house in the US. Located on the Lower East Side, near Five Points, it provided social services like education, healthcare, and legal aid to immigrants and low-income families.
• Other Settlement Houses: Other organizations followed the University Settlement House, establishing similar programs to empower residents and improve their quality of life.
• Religious organizations set up missions in Five Points, providing food, shelter, and religious instruction. Many of them promoted temperance, hoping to reduce alcohol abuse, a major contributor to the area’s social problems.
• The government started to collect garbage more regularly and installed better sewage systems. This helped address public health issues.
• The Tenement House Act of 1867: aimed to improve tenement living conditions by regulating building codes, ventilation, and fire safety.

The Five Point reform efforts laid the groundwork for future improvements in sanitation, housing codes, and social programs. Over time, businesses and government buildings replaced the original tenements. Today, Five Points is a very different neighborhood.

Landmarks and Sites in Five Points

The key locations in Five Points covered:

Mulberry Bend

Mulberry Bend was a narrow, winding section of Mulberry Street, infamous for its overcrowded tenements, high crime rates, and rampant poverty.

The Old Brewery, Five Points New York

The Old Brewery

Once a brewery, this region became an infamous tenement known for its unsanitary and overcrowded conditions. It symbolized the area's destitution with its reputation for crime and poverty.

The Five Points Intersection

Named for the convergence of the five streets: Orange (now Baxter), Anthony (now Worth), Little Water (no longer existent), Cross (now Park), and Mulberry. Five Points intersection was at the epicenter of Five Points’ activities, representing the complexity and chaos of life in the area.

Paradise Square

Paradise Square was surrounded by some of the worst Five Points slums. It was a common gathering place for diverse immigrant communities, among them the Irish, a significant part of Five Points’ population.

Legacy of Five Points

Five Points in New York from the early 19th century to the early 20th century had a significant impact on the city and urban development. The immigration hubs, cultural exchange, and social reform movements had a significant social and demographic impact. Tenement housing, dedicated legislation, and reforms like the Tenement House Act of 1901 raised the standards of urban development and housing. Policing and criminal justice reforms, along with infrastructure development and economic activity, created a legacy of urban renewal in the region.

Five Points strongly influenced immigrant communities and the social reform movement. Five Points became a melting pot of cultures, thanks to the Chinese, Jewish, Italian, and Irish immigrants. Community networks, economic opportunities, cultural contributions, and political mobilization had a major impact on Five Point immigrants. The area drew social reform attention because of its extreme poverty and squalid living conditions. Housing reforms, public health initiatives, social services, charity work, the labor movement, and criminal justice reforms focused on the region’s social development.

The enduring legacy of Five Points on American History is significant, covering the key themes of immigrant experience, social reforms, urban development, socio-political impact, and educational legacy. Five Points remained a symbol of immigrant struggle, a mix of cultures, and served as the foundation of multiculturalism. It was a catalyst for social reforms, housing legislation, and public health improvements. The urban renewal precedent, along with urban development lessons learned in the region, influenced modern urban planning. The political mobilization of immigrants and social justice movements, along with historical awareness and cultural memory, maintained New York’s Five Points legacy.

Remembering Five Points

Five Points’ historical journey covered notorious establishments and dedicated developments to normalize life in the region. While Five Points has many negatives, its rise and legacy are pivotal in the American urban development narrative.

Many argue that Five Points should be remembered as one of New York’s infamous neighborhoods to prevent a repeat of past mistakes.

Discover hidden gems and local favorites with our guides to non-touristy things to do in NYC and Brooklyn. Instead of hitting the usual crowded spots, explore charming neighborhoods, cultural hotspots, and unique dining spots for a true taste of the city. Uncover the best-kept secrets and experience the unique charm of New York City and Brooklyn just like a local.